The Most Important Question to Ask When Buying a Tent
The Most Important Question to Ask When Buying a Tent
How can two tents with identical height and footprint differ in volume by ten cubic feetthe difference between sprawling and spooning? The answer: basic geometry. And its the reason a growing chorus of tent makers thinks volume should join weight, peak height, and square footage in tent specs.
Goto Changyuan to know more.
Volume wasnt needed ten years ago when we shopped at actual stores and could sit in an actual tent. But few stores today dedicate space for setting up tents, and most people shop online. Stats sell tents, yet volume is never included, leaving buyers to base their decision on square footage, tent height, and, particularly, weight.
I suspected it all along, but when I saw the numbers, it was eye opening, says Martin Zemitis, a veteran tent designer at SlingFin, a boutique expedition and backpacking tent maker. Zemitis took SlingFins 28-square-foot, 2-pound-14-ounce 2Lite tent and compared it to a similarly endowed, but nine ounces lighter, competitor.
Because physical tents are slightly different than their computer-generated design, Zemitis hand measured the internal volumes. The 2Lite measured 42 cubic feet. The competitor: 32 cubic feet. Add vestibules and the space gap widened to 34 cubic feetthe equivalent of a four-by-three-foot shed.
Thats a big difference in roomfor cooking, storing packs, and waiting out crappy weatherfor the equivalent of a couple granola bars, concluded Zemitis. Companies have been effectively gaming the system, making tents that look good on paper, calling it a two-person tent, but arent actually livable.
What we need is a combination of an easy-to-digest graphic, like Nemos tent topographic, and hard numbers like square footage or volume. It would comparably illustrate how roomy the tent really is and may even keep more people camping.
To level the market, Zemitis wants all manufacturers to publish tent volume and, more important, a livability indexa ratio of a tents weight to space. Its an easy way to compare apples to apples, he says.
For more information, please visit Camping Tent Factory.
SlingFin isnt the first company to raise this idea. Since at least , a tent working group at ASTM International discussed adding volume to tent specs. Nemo Equipment was the first to voluntarily adopt the new metric, calling it tent topographics, which measures the square footage of its tents at one-foot intervals from the floor to three feet up.
The best way to know how much area youll have for sitting up is the square footage at the three-foot level, where your head is going to be, says Cam Brensinger, founder and CEO of Nemo.
Brensinger dismisses a simple cubic-foot volume metric as ambiguous. Imagine a tent thats 27 inches tall and 20 feet long, he says. Its got huge volume but is completely useless space. Nemo shared its method with the ASTM working group, and Marmot and Sierra Designs have both used it in their dealer marketing material. But only Nemo uses it on its hangtags, website, and catalogs.
Its use is limited if were the only ones doing it, Brensinger says. But all companies are only going to adopt it if someone like REI demands it. REI declined a request for an interview. While online retailer Backcountry.com isnt convinced a volume standard is necessary, the company has floated the idea of working alongside manufacturers to develop a standard of how many people fit in a tent, says Aaron Povine, director of hard goods for Backcountry.
That seems like a crude measure to me. As a tent tester for Outside, Ive slept in dozens of backpacking tents. I think we need numbers we can compare, just like we do with weight. At the same time, I dont think cubic feet and ratios mean much on their own. What we need is a combination of an easy-to-digest graphic, like Nemos tent topographic, and hard numbers like square footage at each elevation or volume. It would comparably illustrate how roomy the tent really is and may even keep more people camping.
I wonder how many people tried backpacking for the first time in an ultralight tent, says Brensinger, but didnt have fun because they were cramped and never did it again.
The company is the world’s best Custom Air Mattress supplier. We are your one-stop shop for all needs. Our staff are highly-specialized and will help you find the product you need.