Pros and Cons of Overseas and U.S. Manufacturing

Overseas Manufacturing

ESCOLO Product Page

Manufacturing in countries like China, Vietnam, and Bangladesh is ubiquitous. A massive chunk of the world's manufacturing is done in countries other than the United States. This is largely due to significantly lower labor costs overseas. Despite the apparent cost advantages, there are pros and cons to manufacturing both overseas and in the U.S., which merit careful consideration before making a decision.

U.S. Manufacturing

When people hear "U.S.," it often piques interest. For companies like Dell or Pfizer, manufacturing plays a crucial role in their business operations. Companies in the U.S. require skilled labor along with expensive machinery, software, and other tools for their manufacturing needs. Interestingly, many U.S. businesses do not engage in manufacturing, relying instead on outsourced production.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Overseas Manufacturing

Cost Reduction

One of the main benefits of outsourcing manufacturing is the ability to cut costs. For instance, if a U.S. company plans to produce a product that costs $12 with $5 for raw materials and 10% for labor, in-house manufacturing can lead to losses. Conversely, outsourcing production can result in a profit.

Greater Flexibility

Outsourcing manufacturing offers flexibility in deciding what the final product will be. For example, if a company wants a specific model of smartphone to be produced in China and then sold in the U.S., they have the freedom to make that decision and plan the logistics accordingly.

Faster and Better Quality

Another advantage is the faster turnaround time and improved product quality. Most companies manufacture overseas to achieve quicker product availability and better quality. Proximity to markets means faster delivery, leading to increased sales and profits.

International Sales

Outsourcing allows companies to quickly manufacture and distribute products across different markets. This flexibility is crucial for establishing an international presence and leveraging local distribution channels to build brand recognition.

Risk Reduction

Outsourcing minimizes many risks associated with in-house manufacturing. Labor costs, for example, are more predictable and usually lower when production is outsourced.

Challenges and Risks of Overseas Manufacturing

Quality Problems

One notable downside is the potential for lower product quality. Companies often employ independent inspectors to ensure product quality, which can be both time-consuming and costly.

Language Barriers

Language and communication barriers can complicate dealings with foreign manufacturers. This necessitates close collaboration to ensure mutual understanding of expectations and policies.

Communication Barriers

Many companies use intermediaries to facilitate communication, which can introduce risks of miscommunication, especially if there is also a language barrier between the manufacturer and the intermediary.

Time-consuming

Outsourcing can be time-consuming due to the hours spent communicating with intermediaries and manufacturers. Ensuring smooth operations can require significant time and effort.

Key Considerations for Manufacturing Location

Global Manufacturing Locations

Countries like China, Mexico, and India offer lower labor costs, making them attractive for manufacturing. However, the U.S. is losing foreign sales to such countries.

Jobs Lost to Low-Cost Countries

The shift to overseas manufacturing has resulted in significant job losses in the U.S. Trade Adjustment Assistance reports the loss of up to 3 million jobs since 1997 due to manufacturing moving abroad.

Foreign Market Share

Since 1997, the U.S. has lost over 8 million jobs to outsourcing and international competition. These losses are affecting various sectors nationwide.

Future Outlook

Countries like China, Mexico, and India are increasingly taking market share in manufacturing. As labor costs rise, companies are turning to other countries for cheaper labor options such as Vietnam and Egypt.

Wage & Benefit Setbacks

Lower labor costs abroad do not equate to better wages for workers. A U.S. Labor Department study found workers in countries like China and Mexico earn no more than their U.S. counterparts, and this trend is contributing to job losses in the U.S.

Challenges for International Manufacturers

Outsourcing can sometimes lead to higher overall costs due to factors like increased shipping expenses. Ensuring low-cost production and shipping efficiencies is crucial for maintaining competitiveness.

Summary of Pros and Cons

Here are some summarized pros and cons of both overseas and U.S. manufacturing.

Pros

• Fewer constraints on production, quality control, and resources
• Lower costs in labor, shipping, and materials
• Better quality control on products manufactured overseas
• Access to a wider market without dealing with tariffs and customs
• Lower tax rates for companies based overseas
• Better work-life balance due to flexible business hours
• Ability to attract global investors and funding

Cons

• Higher labor and material costs than in the U.S.
• More bureaucratic hurdles with local customs and regulatory issues
• Higher costs for shipping and longer delivery times

Due consideration of these points can help companies decide where to manufacture their products based on their specific business needs.

Do you feel like you are struggling with putting "strategy" and "business growth concepts" in place that make a difference? Doing it all is overwhelming! Let’s have an honest discussion about your business and see if the Power of 10 can help you. Click HERE to have a great conversation with our team today.

Written and Published By The Strategic Advisor Board Team
C. 2017-2021 Strategic Advisor Board / M&C All Rights Reserved
www.strategicadvisorboard.com / info@strategicadvisorboard.com

Outsourcing Manufacturing In China - The Ultimate Guide

Ultimate Guide To Ethical And Sustainable Outsourcing Manufacturing In China

Outsourcing manufacturing has been accepted as the best strategy to create growth and profits now that countries outside the U.S. possess better logistics, equipment, and expertise.

Outsourcing manufacturing allows companies to compete effectively, increase profits, and ensure long-term survival. It offers flexibility to ramp up or scale down production based on demand.

While global outsourcing presents opportunities, ethical and sustainable practices remain critical. This guide covers how to benefit from outsourcing manufacturing while maintaining ethical standards and protecting the environment.

What Is Outsourcing Manufacturing?

Outsourcing manufacturing, or contract manufacturing, involves contracting with a third party to produce goods or services previously done in-house. This can include contract manufacturing, license manufacturing, or subcontract manufacturing. Outsourcing can be domestic or international, often to reduce costs.

Common Outsource Manufacturing Solutions

Outsourcing can be beneficial in various scenarios:

1. Handling excess demand when in-house production can't meet orders.
2. Managing seasonal demand spikes without hiring and laying off staff.
3. Redistributing resources to focus skilled employees on essential tasks.
4. Assisting designers who lack manufacturing expertise.

Benefits Of Outsourcing For Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs)

OEM Problem 1: Slow Innovation

OEMs may struggle with innovation, risking distribution channels to competitors.

OEM Solution:

Outsourcing design, engineering, and testing can relieve pressure on internal teams and provide expert solutions.

OEM Problem 2: Slow Market Response

OEMs need to adapt to market changes but may face challenges in quickly updating products.

OEM Solution: Outsource to Access Materials and Resources

Contract manufacturers can offer the expertise and materials needed to address new market requirements efficiently.

OEM Problem 3: Quality Management

Inconsistent product quality can harm business reputations.

OEM Solution: Outsource to Relieve Pressure on Resources

Outsourcing production to expert manufacturers can improve product quality and reduce costs.

OEM Problem 4: Timely Product Development

Developing and launching new products requires significant investment and timely execution.

OEM Solution: Less Expensive Innovation Testing

Contract manufacturers can provide the infrastructure to test new products cost-effectively.

Outsourcing Needs Analysis Checklist

Businesses must rigorously define their needs and consider key questions to ensure successful outsourcing.

• Understand the process to be outsourced
• Map out process dependencies
• Consider business-value arguments for outsourcing
• Conduct thorough benchmarking
• Choose between total or selective outsourcing
• Decide on single or multiple vendors
• Evaluate in-sourcing possibilities
• Ensure internal expertise for requirement gathering
• Prepare comprehensive Statements of Work (SOW) and Requests for Proposals (RFP)

What Is Contract Manufacturing?

Contract manufacturing involves outsourcing parts or entire products to specialized manufacturers. These manufacturers may offer services such as consulting, engineering, design, and product development.

Types Of Contract Manufacturing

1. Lease Equipment or Facility

Leasing equipment can be cost-effective for short-term needs.

2. Contract a Labor Force

Temporary labor can address short-term production spikes.

3. Producing Parts of a Whole

Outsourcing specialized parts can improve quality and reduce costs.

4. Full-Scale Production

OEMs can manage production entirely or collaborate with contract manufacturers.

5. Contracting Specific Manufacturing Processes

Specialized manufacturing tasks, such as machining or grinding, can be outsourced.

What Is The Difference Between Outsourcing And Subcontracting?

Outsourcing involves permanently allocating entire jobs or departments to external firms. Subcontracting is temporary and focuses on completing specialized tasks.

Contract Pharma

Contract manufacturing is prevalent in the pharmaceutical industry, allowing companies to cut costs and comply with regulatory constraints by outsourcing production.

Industries That Use Contract Manufacturing

Several industries, including automotive, aerospace, pharmaceuticals, and electronics, use contract manufacturing to reduce costs and improve efficiency.

Choosing The Right Contract Manufacturing Company For Your Needs

Consider factors such as facilities, experience, quality control, reputation, and cost when selecting a contract manufacturer.

Why Manufacturing In China Still Makes Sense

China leads global manufacturing due to its extensive infrastructure, lower labor costs, and access to resources. Outsourcing to China offers numerous benefits, including cost savings, reduced overheads, and access to skilled labor.

Benefits Of Manufacturing In China

1. Services And Skills

China offers a wide range of services, including business process services, IT, and customer support, contributing to manufacturing value.

2. Lower Labor Costs

China provides cost-effective labor, helping reduce production expenses.

3. Closer Proximity to Resources

Access to additional resources streamlines production.

4. Overhead Costs Are Also Much Lower

Lower overhead costs make China an attractive outsourcing destination.

5. Cheaper Ancillary Services

China offers cost-effective warehousing and shipping services.

6. Readily Available Cheap Products

China's manufacturing ecosystem supports low-cost production.

7. Access to Expertise and Technologies

Outsourcing to China provides access to competitive technology and research.

8. Easier Access to Mass Markets in Asia and Europe

China's geographical location facilitates market expansion in Asia and Europe.

9. Faster Service

China's workforce enables rapid production and delivery times.

10. Quality Of Products And Services

High-end companies produce quality products in China.

11. Readily Available Resources

China offers products and services that support efficient manufacturing.

12. Focus

Outsourcing helps businesses focus on core competencies.

13. Support From The Chinese Government

The Chinese government provides incentives and infrastructure for outsourcing.

14. Access To Super-Competitive Startups

China's dynamic business culture fosters innovative startups.

15. City-Based Manufacturing Hubs

Cities like Shanghai support high-tech startups with infrastructure and talent.

16. Flexibility

Outsourcing allows businesses to scale production based on demand.

17. Rapid Prototyping

China supports rapid prototyping through advanced techniques.

18. Specialist Manufacturers

China offers specialized manufacturing skills and equipment.

19. Quicker Scaling

Chinese manufacturers can efficiently scale up production as demand grows.

20. Fast-Paced Innovations and Research

China excels in innovation, offering access to cutting-edge technology.

21. Access To A Large Pool Of Well Educated, Skilled Specialists

China's commitment to education produces a skilled workforce.

22. Easy Market Expansion Opportunities Within China

The growing Chinese market offers substantial opportunities for expansion.

Problems And Solutions For American Companies Outsourcing Manufacturing To China

Despite the benefits, companies may face challenges such as finding the right factory, language barriers, IP risks, shipping logistics, long lead times, high minimum orders, and complex logistics.

1. Finding The Right Factory

Research and develop good relationships with potential manufacturing partners.

2. Language And Cultural Barriers

Hire a local sourcing agent fluent in English and the local language to facilitate communication.

3. No Respect For Copyright And Intellectual Property (IP) Risks

Protect IP with patents, NNN agreements, and building strong relationships with manufacturers.

4. Shipping and logistics

Working with experienced logistics providers or a sourcing agent can ensure cost-effective and timely shipping.

5. Long Lead Times

Use a sourcing agent to manage lead times and ensure timely production.

6. Large Minimum Order Quantities

Work with a sourcing agent to find smaller manufacturers for limited orders.

7. Not Knowing Who You’re Doing Business With

Do thorough due diligence and work with reputable sourcing agents.

8. The Need For In-Person Supervision And Oversight

Hire a local sourcing agent to handle frequent factory visits and project monitoring.

9. Poor Product Quality

Implement frequent quality checks and detailed product specifications to ensure standards.

10. Choosing The Right City For Manufacturing Your Product

Consult a sourcing agent to select the appropriate city based on technical and logistical needs.

11. Complex logistics

A sourcing agent can arrange cost-effective warehousing and logistics solutions.